Minivan vs SUV: Which Rental Fits Your Trip Best?

Pricing can fluctuate, but minivans are often similarly priced to standard SUVs in many markets. In some cases, minivans might even be a bit cheaper due to slightly lower demand, but at peak family vacation times the reverse can be true. Always compare on our site – we show you multiple providers’ rates in real time. Note: Prices depend on season, location, and availability (and under-25 drivers may see higher surcharges regardless of vehicle type). Models vary by provider and location, so an “SUV” could range from basic to luxury influencing price.

Generally yes, especially when all seats are in use. Minivans are designed to maximize cargo volume behind the third row you might fit 3–4 large bags, whereas a similar 3-row SUV might only fit 2 or so. Plus, minivan seats often fold completely flat into the floor, creating a huge storage area when you don’t need all the seats. Some full-size SUVs have removable/foldable seats too, but the floor may not be as flat. If you have lots of luggage or bulky items, a minivan is usually the better bet.

Many full-size SUVs do have three rows, offering 7–8 seatbelts similar to a minivan. However, the third row in SUVs can be tighter on legroom compared to a minivan’s third row. If you have 6-8 adults, a minivan will be more comfortable; if it’s a mix of adults and kids, an SUV’s seating might suffice. Always check the specific model (we list “7-passenger” or “8-passenger” in the vehicle details on our site). And remember, passenger count includes the driver – e.g., a “7-passenger SUV” means 6 + driver.

Both vehicle types are built with safety in mind, but minivans tend to have lower centers of gravity which can reduce rollover risk and are engineered for families (lots of airbags, child safety features). SUVs, especially large ones, are very safe in many respects but their height can make them slightly more prone to rollovers in extreme maneuvers or high winds. That said, modern SUVs have stability control to mitigate this. In crash tests, minivans and SUVs both perform well overall. The exact model matters (a large newer SUV with advanced safety tech vs an older minivan, for example). Always drive cautiously either type is safe for normal use, and rental vehicles from major providers are late-model with up-to-date safety features.

If you expect snow, ice, or unpaved mountain roads, an SUV is usually the safer choice due to available AWD/4WD and higher clearance. Many minivans are front-wheel drive; some offer all-wheel drive but they still have lower clearance (snow can pack under the vehicle). For a ski trip or mountain camping, we’d suggest an SUV and even then, request all-wheel drive and winter tires if available (some providers in snowy regions equip SUVs appropriately or offer tire chains). If your trip is primarily highways and city streets (even in winter, where roads are plowed), a minivan with good tires can manage but check weather forecasts and plan accordingly. Availability of AWD minivans is limited and varies by location.

It’s pretty comparable, with a slight edge to smaller SUVs in some cases. Minivans are built on car-like platforms and often have efficient V6 engines, so you might get around ~22–28 MPG on the highway. A midsize or full-size SUV might get ~20–26 MPG. It really depends on the model for example, a hybrid SUV could beat a gasoline minivan in MPG. Overall, you won’t see a huge difference; expect to pay a bit more at the pump with either compared to a compact car. If fuel is a major concern, consider the specific models offered (we show vehicle or “or similar” you can look up that model’s MPG).

Minivans are built for convenience: power sliding doors mean kids won’t ding the next car in the parking lot; lower floors make it easy to step in with armloads of gear; and there are often more small storage cubbies and chargers spread around. If you have infants or toddlers, the wide opening and foldable second-row seats make installing car seats and accessing the third row far less hassle than in an SUV. Also, minivans typically have better visibility (big windows all around) which is great for sightseeing and safer lane changes. These little ease-of-use factors can really improve a family trip. SUVs, in turn, often have the benefit of towing capacity if you need to haul a trailer or boat, most minivans can’t, whereas many truck-based SUVs can tow.

When comparing on our site, you’ll see example models (“Chrysler Pacifica or similar”, “Chevy Tahoe or similar”). Rental agencies don’t guarantee exact models you’re booking a vehicle category. That means you can choose “Minivan” or “Full-Size SUV”, but not the exact make/model. The examples listed give an idea of size and features. If you have a strong preference (say, need a particular feature like a DVD player or AWD), you can call the provider after booking to request it, but it’s not guaranteed. Tip: Book early, especially for holiday seasons these larger vehicles sell out fast in popular locations.