Find your perfect Indiana rental car in seconds! Enter your pickup location and travel dates above to instantly compare real-time rates from all major brands plus trusted local companies. Whether you need an economy car for Indianapolis business travel or a spacious SUV for exploring Indiana's state parks, our platform shows all options with transparent pricing. Filter by features, read reviews, and book with confidence, most reservations include free cancellation for ultimate flexibility.
Welcome to Indiana, the Crossroads of America where racing legends are born and Midwest hospitality thrives! From the thundering excitement of the Indianapolis 500 to the covered bridges of Parke County and the stunning dunes along Lake Michigan, Indiana offers surprising diversity best explored by car. This page is your complete resource for finding the perfect rental car at unbeatable prices. We combine insider knowledge of Indiana's roads with access to 40+ rental companies, ensuring you get both the best deal and the local expertise to make your Indiana adventure unforgettable.
Indiana's attractions span far beyond Indianapolis, making a rental car essential for experiencing the Hoosier State fully:
Our Indiana Car Rental Advantages
Today's Top Indiana Car Rental Deals
(Prices updated hourly, Indiana shows significant variation during racing and festival seasons)
(Note: Rates shown for Indianapolis Airport. May pricing reflects 40-60% increases due to Indianapolis 500. Book early for events!)
Driving in Indiana: Local Knowledge Essentials
Indiana's roads range from rural simplicity to urban complexity. Here's your guide to confident Hoosier State driving:
Amazing Indiana Road Trip Ideas
Indiana's central location and diverse attractions create excellent road trip opportunities:
Indianapolis to Brown County State Park (Artist Colony & Fall Foliage)
Distance: 60 miles south (1.5 hours each way) Route: SR-37 South to SR-46 East to Nashville Highlights: Escape Indianapolis for Indiana's most scenic county. The drive passes through rolling hills that explode with color in fall. Nashville (the town, not Tennessee!) offers a delightful artist colony with 300+ shops, galleries, and studios. Browse handmade crafts, art, and antiques along Van Buren Street.
Brown County State Park, Indiana's largest, provides 16,000 acres of beauty. Hike to Weed Patch Hill for panoramic views or mountain bike the challenging Aynes Trail. The park's Nature Center educates about local ecology. Nearby attractions include T.C. Steele State Historic Site (famous Hoosier artist's home) and Story Inn (haunted historic restaurant). Fall weekends bring crowds for spectacular foliage, arrive early.
Tips: October peak foliage creates heavy traffic, visit midweek if possible. Nashville parking is limited during festivals. Many shops close Mondays. Bring cash as some vendors don't accept cards. The narrow, winding roads require careful driving. Book accommodations months ahead for fall weekends. Check Brown County's website for festival schedules.
Northern Indiana Amish Country Experience
Distance: 150 miles from Indianapolis to Shipshewana Route: US-31 North to US-6 East Highlights: Journey to America's third-largest Amish community for a glimpse into simpler times. The drive north passes through flat farmland before entering buggy country. Shipshewana hosts the massive flea market (Tuesdays/Wednesdays, May-October) with 900+ vendors. Take a buggy ride, tour an Amish farm, or watch furniture being handcrafted.
Stop at Rise'N Roll Bakery for famous cinnamon caramel donuts. Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury serves authentic Amish cooking family-style. Menno-Hof museum explains Anabaptist history. The Blue Gate Theater presents family-friendly shows. Countryside shops sell handmade quilts, furniture, and crafts. Experience the peaceful pace of horse-drawn transportation and wave-powered washing machines.
Tips: Respect Amish preferences against photography. Many businesses close Sundays. Share the road carefully with buggies, pass slowly with wide berth. Bring cash as many places don't accept cards. Best visited Tuesday/Wednesday for flea market or Thursday-Saturday for shops. Book guided tours to access Amish homes/farms respectfully.
Lake Michigan Dunes Adventure
Distance: 160 miles from Indianapolis to Indiana Dunes Route: I-65 North to I-94 West Highlights: Discover Indiana's surprising 45-mile Lake Michigan coastline. Indiana Dunes National Park preserves 15,000 acres of dunes, wetlands, prairies, and forests. Climb the 3 Dune Challenge (300+ feet elevation gain) for lake views. Swim at West Beach or walk the Portage Lakefront. The park's biodiversity ranks fourth among national parks.
Visit Chesterton's European Market (Saturdays, May-October) before entering the park. The Bailly Homestead and Chellberg Farm show 19th-century life. For urban beach experience, head to Michigan City's Washington Park Beach with its historic lighthouse. Blue Chip Casino provides Vegas-style gaming. Return via Fair Oaks Farms for agricultural tours and cheese sampling.
Tips: Summer weekends fill beaches early, arrive by 9 AM for parking. Swim only at lifeguarded beaches due to dangerous currents. Bring water and sun protection for dune climbing. Check for prescribed burns that may close trails. Chicago skyline visible on clear days from high dunes. Avoid I-80/94 during Chicago rush hours.
Frequently Asked Questions
Depends on your itinerary. If staying downtown and walking to attractions, rent only for day trips. The city's Cultural Trail connects many downtown sites. However, reaching the Motor Speedway, airport, or suburbs requires a car. Rideshare costs add up quickly for multiple trips. Many visitors rent cars just for specific days to explore outside Indianapolis. Consider your hotel's parking fees, downtown hotels charging $30+/night might make selective rental more economical.
Downtown Indianapolis parking rates increased to $2/hour at meters (February 2025), payable via ParkIndy app or meter. Garages run $15-25/day. Event parking near stadiums costs $20-40. Many downtown hotels charge $25-35/night additional for parking. Mass Ave and Fountain Square have limited street parking, use garages. Outside downtown, parking is generally free and abundant. Broad Ripple nightlife district has paid parking on weekends. Always read signs carefully for restrictions.
The Indiana Toll Road runs east-west across northern Indiana (I-80/I-90) for 157 miles. Tolls are distance-based, with the full length costing about $12 for cars. It accepts E-ZPass and offers pay-by-plate options. No other Indiana highways have tolls. Indianapolis has no toll roads at all. If your route includes Chicago, I-65 provides a toll-free alternative to the toll road. For occasional use, pay online at indianatollroad.org within 7 days to avoid fees.
Indianapolis 500 week (late May) sees dramatic price increases, expect to pay 2-3x normal rates. Economy cars that normally cost $35/day jump to $80-100/day. Many locations require 3-5 day minimum rentals during race week. Book at least 2-3 months ahead for any May Indianapolis rental. Similar increases occur during Brickyard 400 (August) and major conventions. Consider staying outside Indianapolis (Lafayette, Columbus) for better rates during events.